Would Jake and Brett have been together if Jake didn't suffer the war scar?
As the title said, would Jake and Brett got together if Jake didn't suffer from his war scar? One could argue that if Jake was able to function in moments of intimacy, Brett and Jake would have hit it off well. It is mentioned in the passage that they have tried it before, but it fell apart because Jake and Brett couldn't relieve each other's urges. In theory, if this was their only problem, Jake would able to have a relationship with Brett if he didn't suffer a war injury. I argue otherwise. The reason why Jake and Brett got so close is that they were able to comfort each other when they were in distress. Jake lost his manliness during the war and Brett lost her true love during the war. Because they were able to relieve each other's pain, they were able to grow closer and form an unbreakable emotional bond. If Jake didn't lose his manliness during the war, he could very much be compared to Robert Cohn who Brett shook off constantly. He is obsessed with Brett...